Season 8: Episode 4

Season 8: Episode 6

Evil Lives Here (2016)

Season 8: Episode 5

The Prom Night Killer

TMDb

Air Date:

2025-12-06

Genre

Crime Documentary

Release Date

2016

End Date

2025

Episode Description

Jessi Toronjo went to a sleepover in 1989 thinking her stepbrother, Jeffrey Pelley, was at his senior prom. She spent the next 13 years believing someone else committed the unspeakable crime that weekend, only to discover she knew the killer all along.

503Weekly views

503Monthly views

5Total views

1

1

Something Is Different About Robbie

My Brother's Secret

In Love with the Devil

Home Sweet Nightmare

I Invited Him In

In the Lion's Cage

The Last Blanco

Fear Thy Father

Something Wasn’t Right

Master Manipulator

The Grim Reaper

We Looked Happy

You Know My Brother's Name

Evil Undercover

Under His Thumb

He's Still My Son

I Was His First Victim

Is This the Night I Die?

I Hate Being Daddy's Girl

I Wish I'd Turned Around

One Of His Women

Poisoned by Love

He Was a Good Man to Me

I Tried to Prevent This

The Face of My Torturer

Our Secret Identity

Until We Meet Again

He Knew What He Was

They Let Him Out

I Have to Do the Right Thing

My Twisted Sister

It was All Judith

I Raised a Sociopath

The Nights I Don't Remember

My Brother Made History

While I Was Gone

I Wished My Son Were Dead

You Have to Get Out

I Should Have Killed Him Myself

He Almost Got Away With It

He Said There Were More of Them

He Won't Tell Us Why

The Werewolf Butcher

I Killed Dirty John

I Didn't Know It Was Blood

I Don’t Believe in Forgiveness

Momma Made Me Help

The Prom Night Killer

My Son Broke My Heart

They Found Them In Storage

What If He Was Innocent?

My Son is Damaged Goods

I Don't Know Why He Spared Me

He Pretends to Be Human

They Said I Killed My Brother

He Lived A Double Life

To Infinity and Back

He Was My Hero and a Monster

I Still Love My Daddy

I Was Warned and Didn't Listen

He Was Born Evil

Nobody Believed Me

We All Die Tonight

He Fed Them to Gators

Locked in the Closet

What if He Gets Out?

I Will Always Be Scared of Him

He Kept Her in a Tree Stump

He Was A False Prophet

Keeping My Brother's Secret

She Should Be Left to Die

Divorce? Never. Murder? Maybe.

He Should Have Died Sooner

He Tied Me Up, Too

Sleeping With The Enemy

A Special Place in Hell

He Pretended to Save Me

I Found His Confession

I Watched Daddy Bury Mommy

I Made It Out Alive

Scratch My Murderous Itch

Kill Him Save Yourself

He Called It "The Need”

He Looks Like the Killer on TV

Fantasising and Hunting

The Hole in the Backyard

Ménage à Terror

Sisters in Silence

We're Glad Mom is Dead

Trapped in a House of Torture

My Brother Let the Evil In

He Had a Torture Chamber

She Knew It Was Goodbye

I Wanted My Father To Die

Three-and-A-Half Hours of Hell

The Butcher and the Box

Terror in the Wilderness

She Hid the Knife in a Toybox

He Brought Roses and a Gun

Murder in the House of Prayer

I Saw Myself on Tape

He Shot Through My Heart

He Used a Chainsaw

He Asked Me to Be His Hitman

She Called To Say I Killed Them

He Saved Her Life, Then Took It

Our Little Sister, the Monster

They Stole My Childhood

Ted Bundy Was His Idol

My Wicked Stepmother

Greed, Jealousy, Malice

A Demon on Her Back

Not My Brother's Keeper

My First Love Hunted People

My Father Let the Darkness In

Mom Lured Me Into a Trap

I Died for a Moment

Three Times a Killer

He Took My Soul

He Haunts Me Everyday

Thirty Years of Hell

He Was Whistling as He Did It

I Know Who the Real Monster Is

My Love Put a Gun to My Head

Mom Said I Was Dying

Trapped Abroad With a Psychopath

The Blood on My Brother's Hands

Why Is Daddy on TV?

It Was Like Watching a Demon

Our Brother by Blood

Mother’s Day Malice

Like a Monster from the Movies

I Am Not My Father

He’ll Kill Me Next

He's One Hundred Percent a Monster

They All Saw His Evil

The Black Widow of Pennsylvania

The Granny Killer

He Put Me in the Dog Cage

Comments

The comment field is only for members. Login, Register